Monday, December 5, 2011

Authorship

Kaki bakar (1995), talk about a father who struggles to advocate his sprit and principle in living with his family. However, he meets with challenges and the reality stop him from being in line with his way of doing until he ended his lives.

On the other hand, Jogho talk about bull fighting Patani Malay community of Southern Thailand (Jogho, 1997). Even they are both Malay, we can see the differences. They have different struggle but they care about each other and willing to help regardless of ethic.

The authorship approach is Technique of the self by text because author aware of authorship and consider viewer by place his role of author in text in his directing film. He completely understands his filming style and he well manipulate mise en scene in full control. He is moving forward from linear to progressive style by showing flashback scene.

I like the slow dolly tracking shot and most of the shot that pan to top in the end. In kaki bakar, he track right review more mise en scene and character specifically. In Jogho, he track left and right in the scene of bull arena and pan to top to show people. The tracking shot he used is a different mise en shot. We seldom see it in usual Malay film. He goes beyond from tracking shot to crane shot to show police. I prefer the progress he shows now as he inserts variety of shot and more technique. From tracking going left to right, now he added dolly and moves up and down.

Haunting sound track is also one of my like because it act as a cue that terrible things or unpleasant will happen soon or in future. U Wei use haunting or eerie sound that comprises of diegetic and non-diegetic sounds. Example in kaki bakar is the music soundtrack and the prayers at night in beginning and the middle part of the films. Viewer cannot hear the dialogue clearly because the background sound is too loud and the noise is annoying. The haunting sound continues to appear in many scenes. One example is in the journey when they go back home by lorry. Next example is when carpet are drop on the floor and the sound stopped when kakang gather them to divide the allocation of work. It started again when their family members carry the carpet, when kakang spoiled the carpet and when Tuan Kassim indicates the impact to his family by saying “I want you to understand”. It also appears when kakang accidentally fall when he get down the staircase. It acts like a preview to audiences that something bad going to happen to him without him knowing. When the story progress, the haunting music are heard when Tok Empat announce the conclusion that his paid will be deducted to paid the ruined of carpet and in the whole process of kakang trying to burn the rubber farm until Tuan Kassim started his first line. In Jogho, the music is professionally handled. Example in Jogho is when aral hit mamat. It is better mixing and with more control by adding ambient sound with right frequency and pitch.

He show similar theme that portray identity. Generally Malay film show middle class businessman in urban. However, U Wei shows hyper masculinity in rural village and the relationship between father and son. Example is when kakang slaps Harjo because he doesn’t want Harjo to be weak. He wants Harjo to show his Javanese spirit and teach him to be strong in order to be a real man. In addition, he establishes adat and involves in die and dealing matter. This is against the mainstream where he emphasizes on male’s characteristic and discusses on tradition of Malay male and people around him. I dislike the representation here. Though he always mentions on how important to be masculine, he himself did not show the quality and condition of a masculine man enough. He did explain to kusumo as how he won the battle in the situation where no one revolt. Nevertheless, he did not fight back or he couldn’t fight. This shows his vulnerability in front of higher class or authority party. Therefore, kusumo ran away when the incidents is not what he wish even he tried to help. I dislike kusomo and the ending where kusomo is expressing his father’s merit while running away. He knows his father is a brave solider and rich, capable captain unlike others. He is further elaborated as the one who worked for entire family and the one who taught the Dutch even with a flaw on his leg. However, kakang has no point of return. Kusomo might have tried to fight for honor but he failed. He couldn’t help at all. As an audience, I feel dissatisfy because he is the only sons who can understand his father but he is also the one who caused his father death. What a sad closing when sons disappoint his father’s expectation, while other family member could not help and other people would not know how to help. In the end, I feel pity to the father as hyper masculinity should be presented in a perfect resolution in my mind.

At the same time, we noticed sense of dignity and power are seen across two films. Ethic struggle and social inequality are shown in indirect way. In kaki bakar, Javanese and Malay are not treated equally. Weak working class is unable to fight with boss. Father has to pay for the carpet even he make effort to meet tok empat. In jogho, polis has the right to catch mamat without telling any detail to his family. There is no justice, freedom or power for one’s right here. In jogho, a person cannot go Kelantan without a Malaysian IC. Nevertheless, they send their son to study in Kelantan. They keep their spirit go on where they are proud of their origin and culture practices.

Besides, U Wei shows the theme as father knows best. Father shouts at his son to get back into the track when his son is injured as if everyone needs to listen to him. Father shouts again when mother try to get some water for his son as if he knows get back into the track is best for them. He speaks on the same sentences to kusumo when kusumo tried to strive for abolishment of compensation during the negotiation of carpet’s issue. Another example is when mother who cares about his son, trying to wipe off the blood on her son’s face, this action is rejected by father because he believes that man doesn’t act like women that to be coddled. Next example is father who found the place as if he understand everyone’s need as mentioned in the dialogue “father know best” by other family members. Moreover, when mother advised father not to move around, father stick to his own plan and own thought. He asserts that their children can receive education without going to school. He suggested himself to teach religion, his wife and sister to teach on praying. In Jogho, Mamat says the final word to fid aral with expensive rice. The wife argues with him but she listen to mamat’s decision. Both films have shown how father plays an important part in family.

Family and unconditional love is seen in both films. In kaki bakar, family is connected by tradition and value. Family also being emphasized by father that without the existing of family, a person is nothing. When a person chooses to be stick, he or she should adhere to family. In Jogho, family is developed into community based. Other family is taking into consideration as well. He takes care of Patanese as part of his family. They have strong sense of community. Furthermore, people in both films are remind to remember their roots, acknowledge origin and cannot betray heritage.

Role of male and female is in sophisticated representation. In Kaki Bakar, wife is submissive to husband while daughter has more voice. In Jogho, female has more vocal. Example: minah voice her opinion and argue with mamat that they have not enough money. We see her speaks on her dissatisfaction when she washes dishes, she does not keep her voice in heart. This also shows dynamic representation of male and female. Female is given a voice but they are not disrespect. They are told to work together to have a better family.

Social and political aspect is shown in both films. In kaki bakar, father wants kusumo to be creative, seek knowledge and experience by travelling around so that he is not spoofed or waiting to be served like other Malay family. He critic Malay society as the one who always wait for subsidy money as describe in black colour and not cleaned enough. In jogho, we see conflict between Kelantan and Patanese. Kelantan is portrayed as weak and Patanese is portrayed stronger.

Conclusion, u wei’s idea of Malay is showing progress in film as well as he grow in his authorship.

References

Amimu, Plot summary for Jogho (1997). Retrieved December 4, 2011 from http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0241604/plotsummary